Identification Criteria for Evaluating the Quality of Implementation of Tourism Destination Development Policies

Abstract

For decades, the criteria for measuring tourism policy implementation have tended to be dominated by studies of government and public administration, leaving tourism science merely an object. This article aims to identify and synthesize criteria for measuring the implementation of tourism destination development policies in accordance with Sharia-compliant tourism. The research method used is descriptive qualitative with the approach used being a review of related literature by adapting and modifying research results through the process of identification, composition, visualization, decomposition, and adaptation. The results of the study indicate that the assessment of policy implementation has so far been under the culture of public administration including communication, resources, disposition, bureaucratic structure. From these parameters, only communication and resources can be integrated into the culture of tourism science that focuses on tourists and tourism destinations. The integration of communication and resources produces 9 criteria and 50 indicators for measuring the quality of implementation of Sharia Tourism destination development policies for further empirical research adaptation processes, namely 1) Community 2) Tourism Consumers 3) Islamic Clothing 4) Tourist Attractions 5) Tourist Accommodation 6) Public Facilities 7) Products with halal logos 8) Information Services; 9) Services that ensure the security of personal belongings. This study contributes to the field by introducing a novelty consisting of the implementation of tourism destination development policies that are consistent with tourism science, cultural values, and Sharia principles.